You Can Do Better Than the School of Hard Knocks

A founder I am working with started his career in a warehouse. He has no university degree.  He learned the business by doing nearly every job in it, and he learned people by serving customers since he was a teenager.

He calls it the school of hard knocks. It worked. A decade later, he leads a company that private equity bought at eight times earnings and that may now sell for twelve or thirteen.

Now he sees his second exit on the horizon, and he faces an important question:

Why can’t my successor learn the way I did?

The instinct is natural. The path that made you feels like the path that works. Throw them in. Let them figure it out. Struggle builds leaders.

But a sale changes the math.

The school of hard knocks has no timeline and no method. It develops leaders slowly, often by accident, and it leaves no evidence that buyers can see.

And a buyer will ask one question about your team: can they run this without you? If the honest answer is "we will find out," you have just lowered your multiple. Buyers pay for proven continuity. They discount dependence on the founder.

So we are being more thoughtful than the school of hard knocks.  We are:

  • Defining the role the successor must fill in the next version of the company

  • Giving each candidates real assignments, with support behind them.

  • Setting up feedback loops with evidence.

  • Writing it own, so the next owners has confidence rather than hope.

There is a personal side, too. This founder wants the people who built the business with him to thrive after he steps away. Leaving them to sink or swim is not loyalty. Preparing them deliberately is.

Natalie Michael

Natalie Michael is the Managing Partner of CEO Next Chapter, a firm focused on guiding CEO Transitions and Coaching CEOs who are thinking about what is next.

Next
Next

Letting Go of the Vine: What Microsoft and Disney Teach Us About CEO Succession